TV Review: "Elongated Journey Into Night"

The current TV show The Flash began on the second season of the TV show Arrow. Early episodes of the season featured mentions of STAR Labs building a particle accelerator in Central City, which had previously been mentioned in the first season. Later, Barry Allen (Grant Gustin) himself showed up and wound up being the one to suggest Oliver Queen (Stephen Amell) wear a mask to disguise his identity as the Green Arrow. His appearance ended with him being struck by a wave from the malfunctioning particle accelerator back home in Central City.

The next season saw The Flash debut as a spinoff TV show. The two shows would further spinoff into DC's Legends of Tomorrow and The Flash would be the first to crossover with sister show Supergirl. The Flash would have its identity as a show about a super-powered hero, his allies, and the many villains he would face in Central City.

Seems like Ralph Dibny would be a perfect fit, right?

Well, in the first season's episode "Power Outage," Dr. Harrison Wells mentions that he'd hurt a lot of people the night of the Particle Accelerator explosion, and mentions Ralph's name with two characters who were confirmed dead, and another character who would be revealed to not be dead later in the season. The general consensus was that this universe's Ralph Dibny was deceased.

Or was he?

As the current season of The Flash went into its last few months, it was revealed they were casting a character who would be a lot of work for the special effects crew. That role was revealed to indeed be Ralph Dibny, who would be officially confirmed to be played by Hartley Sawyer.

How could this be so, though? Well, over its first three seasons, there had been various time travel plots on The Flash that changed details of the past, so Ralph not being dead could easily be explained away. In any case, fans got very, very excited.

Let's just preface by saying that this take on Ralph was going to be very different from the classic version we know from The Flash #112 and onward. This is just about bog standard for the "Arrowverse" shows.

The Season 4 story arc features the riders of a bus being hit by dark energy, becoming metahumans. The STAR Labs team finds a card from Ralph Dibny's private investigation firm in the possession of the deceased bus driver. Wondering if he was one of the riders, Barry and Joe West (Jesse L. Martin) visit the firm to ask if Ralph was on the bus. Ralph denies it, but Joe and Barry soon find that this was a lie.

Barry and Ralph have a history. Ralph had been a senior officer in the Central City Police Depeartment, but Barry caught him forging evidence, which caused him to be fired. Ralph had his reasons as he didn't want a guilty man to get away, but he still made the wrong call. So, this take on Ralph isn't quite the squeaky clean good guy we first met in the Silver Age, but it does play into the original story's themes of Barry being suspicious of him. Just this time, he has valid reasons. Luckily, the episode gives us a redemption arc of sorts, one that promises to play out further through the season.

In addition to Ralph's plot, STAR Labs tech Cisco Ramon (Carlos Valdes, playing the Arrowverse version of Vibe) meets his girlfriend's father Breacher (Danny Trejo), who decides to "hunt" him for twenty-four hours. If Cisco survives, he can continue dating Gypsy (Jessica Camacho). And by "survive," I certainly mean that.

Hartley Sawyer is incredible as Ralph, and surprisingly, actually looks a lot like the classic character. His hair isn't quite the red we see in the comics, though it does have a ruddy look to it. Considering how loose the Arrowverse is with appearances, it's fine. Sawyer is engagingly entertaining in the role, being comic and fitting in well with the rest of the cast, and I very much look forward to seeing how the character will develop going forward.

The special effects are nicely done and with the usual suspension of disbelief are easy to accept, which is surprising for a TV show. Perhaps they wouldn't work so well if transferred directly to a cinematic movie screen, but on television, they look great.

Overall, "Elongated Journey Into Night" was one great hour of television that left me beaming, and if you're a fan of the character, you'll find a lot to love.

Viewers in the US may view "Elongated Journey Into Night" at no charge during a limited availability window on the CW website and app. With the current licensing agreement, the entire fourth season of The Flash will be available on Netflix in June, 2018. Digital versions of the episode may be purchased on iTunes, Amazon Instant Video, Vudu, Google Play and other retailers of digital video content. Blu-Ray and DVD copies of the season are expected to be available for sale in or by September, 2018.

Non-US viewers should check their local listings, the websites of the channels that air The Flash, and digital video retailers.

Recommended Elongated Man comics


I'd posted this before on my personal "blog about whatever the heck I want" blog, but here it is, a little expanded. Elongated, if you will.

Just, if you're looking for some Elongated Man stories to pick up, here's some of my recommendations. I'd actually suggest a lot more of the Detective Comics stories and the appearances in The Flash, but I broke it down to some of the more notable ones. Here's the list of Ralph's appearances on ComicVine if you want to explore further.


The Flash #112 - "The Mystery of the Elongated Man!" When the Elongated Man arrives in Central City, the Flash is wary of his tendency to help people and getting attention. When he notices some unsolved crimes, he begins to suspect the Elongated Man of committing them.

The Flash #119 - "The Elongated Man's Undersea Trap!" While skin diving on his honeymoon, Ralph disappears. Sue calls in the Flash, who discovers alien fishermen who kidnap humans for slaves.

The Flash #124 - "The Space-Boomerang Trap!" One of the more iconic Flash and Elongated Man team ups. When Captain Boomerang uses time-traveling boomerangs to commit crimes and appear innocent at the same time, it brings the attention of beings from another dimension, forcing Flash and Elongated Man to join forces with the villain.

Detective Comics #327 - "Ten Miles To Nowhere!" The start of Ralph's Detective Comics stories, which continued to #383 before going to irregular appearances. While traveling, Ralph notices that his odometer mysteriously gained ten miles overnight. Investigating, he cracks a crime ring.

Detective Comics #331 - "Museum of Mixed-Up Men!" Ralph's first team up with Batman. Arriving in Gotham City, Ralph joins Batman's investigation of a gang that uses a device that causes people's faces to change.

Detective Comics #355 - "The Tantalizing Trouble of the Tripod Thieves!" Ralph spots jewelry thieves floating away against their will and follows them to discover Zatanna, who winds up enlisting his help in finding her father. This was part of a running story throughout several DC titles that culminated in Justice League of America #51, which Ralph appeared in.

Justice League of America #105 - "Specter in the Shadows!" Ralph is inducted into the Justice League and calls them in when he and Sue witness a gang of putty men raid a museum.

The Flash #252-253 - "Double Dose of Danger!" and "Don't Mess With The Molder!" A two-part story in which Ralph drinks a dose of gingold at super speed when he's recruited by the Flash to investigate a mysterious phantom gang. The "speed-charged" substance causes Ralph to take on the villainous persona of "The Molder," who can change the shape of whatever—or whoever—he touches, part one ending with him reducing the Flash to a puddle on live television.


Detective Comics #500 - "The Final Mystery of Edgar Allan Poe!" Ralph and Sue spot a raven saying "Nevermore!" This leads Ralph to discover an attempted murder, and find a never before published story by Edgar Allan Poe.

Detective Comics #572 - "The Adventure of the Lost Adventure!" Part of a book-long crossover with Batman, Robin and Slam Bradley (and a surprise mystery guest), Ralph foils a plot to steal a long-lost Sherlock Holmes manuscript from 221B Baker Street.

Secret Origins (Vol. 2) #30 - "The Home Stretch." A new version of Ralph's origin based on how the character had developed since his debut, including how he met Sue. It's told in a framing sequence of Ralph returning to his hometown.

Ralph and Sue frequently appeared in Justice League Europe and Justice League International.

Elongated Man #1-4 - 1994 saw Ralph get his very own miniseries. A bit goofy, Ralph and Sue head to Modora where an old Justice League villain attempts to break them apart.
Batman: Gotham Knights #41 - Ralph and Sue meet a very interesting "fan" at a book signing.

Identity Crisis #1-7 - Probably one of the two most controversial stories to include on this list, this story has a huge focus on the Dibnys. Ralph is on a stakeout when he gets an alert from Sue and hurries home, discovering her murdered and the body burned. The other heroes of the DC universe set out to find the killer, revealing disturbing secrets.

Formerly Known As The Justice League #1-6 - A miniseries featuring a comical take on several former League members, including Ralph and Sue. Note that this and its sequel take place prior to Identity Crisis.

JLA Classified #4-9 - "I Can't Believe it's Not The Justice League!" A sequel to Formerly Known As The Justice League.

52 #1-52 - This series follows many characters through the DC universe. Ralph is one of them as he seeks a way to be reunited with Sue after her death in Identity Crisis.

Booster Gold (Vol. 2) #15 - "Reality Lost, Part One" While time traveling, Booster Gold runs into Ralph.

Convergence: Justice League of America #1-2 - Part of the Convergence crossover, this one takes a peek at a world where Ralph and Sue still live, and Ralph is still an active hero.

Secret Six #1-14 (2014-2016) - Ralph and Sue's new incarnations in Earth Prime make their debut as they work to take down the Riddler.

The Elongated Man's Undersea Trap!

 Here's the story from The Flash #119. It's a very important story for the future of Ralph as we know him, because we can honestly say that after this story, he was never the same.

The team that introduced Ralph is back for this milestone: Julius Schwartz as editor, John Broome writing, Carmine Infantino on pencils, Joe Giella on inks, and Gaspar Saladino lettering.

This splash page gives us another exciting tease of what's to come in the story with Ralph and Barry in action against what appear to be aliens with Ralph directly attacking one in what would be a flying saucer, except it's on wheels.

Then you notice the rocky outcropping at the top and see that this must be some underground place. Infantino once again did great work here to convey the action of the moment.

Heck, blow this up and make it into a poster, it's that good.

There is so much to talk about on this first page. Ralph is married now to Sue Dearbon, a debutante. And note: Dearbon. For the longest time, I thought it was Dearborn, but there's no second r. Some sites and other media get this wrong, but honestly, it's an easy enough mistake.

Ralph, as you remember, was a kid from an unremarkable family in Waymore, Nebraska. Sue being a debutante means she's a far higher class, and her marrying Ralph means she's married below her own class. Yeah, Ralph said he's made a lot of money from media appearances, but if he's gotten married and might want to start a family, he might want to look at getting some more eventually...

The thing that frustrates fans of the character is that this is the first time we've met Sue, who becomes a mainstay of Ralph's life. We're told nothing of how they met or how Ralph convinced her to marry him. Later stories would flashback and reveal that Ralph crashed her debut ball. Specifically Secret Origins #30 and Identity Crisis #1. Maybe more, but I haven't read all of the Elongated Man stories yet... Why do you think I started this blog? And while Ralph wasn't quite the most physically attractive person around, his personality and the energy he brought to the debut ball was what made Sue fall for him.

The question that arises here is if Ralph is still doing the whole secret identity act. You can see that he had the Flash as his best man, and apparently, Barry can't keep Ralph's identity a secret... Some fans believe that of course a legal wedding would require Ralph to reveal his name. The confirmation that Ralph didn't have a secret identity would be made in a few issues time, and was not a big plot point. So, Ralph revealing his secret identity at the same time he married Sue would be quite the romantic and public move that would feel just so typical of the character.

Well, I just spent four paragraphs on the first panel of this page. Well, moving on, Infantino gives us the first look at Mr. and Mrs. Dibny together and they make quite the cute couple. Sue would undergo many style changes over the years, and most of the time, her hair would be depicted as jet black. In 52 and Secret Six, however, her hair was colored brown.

Okay, Ralph goes skin diving and it seems he uses his regular costume for it. The idea of him elongating while swimming does make for an interesting visual, especially when you try to imagine it in motion.

Suddenly, Ralph is zapped by a paralyzing beam and that's the last we see of him for several pages.

It wasn't until recently I realized that Sue is looking over the edge of the boat. Previously, I'd thought she was sitting over a wireless telegraph sending a message out. She heads to the nearest town and sends a telegram to Barry Allen, who they were told to contact if they needed the Flash. (Which likely means Ralph has deduced Barry's identity.) Barry luckily has the weekend off and hurries to the hotel where Sue is staying.



I'm going to have to warn you that if you were expecting these early stories with Sue to have her be a remarkably strong female character, you're going to be disappointed. Fortunately, as the comics continued and the society reading and creating these stories progressed, it got better. But we do have quite a few well-intentioned bits of sexism coming our way.

Sue fills Barry in on all the details she knows and Barry remembers hearing about skin divers going missing in the area. (Funny no one mentioned that to Ralph who would definitely take an interest.) He prepares to go underwater at super speed, but Sue insists he wear diving gear.

As it turns out, Sue has the right idea because as Barry goes underwater, he spots strange fish-men who ride on underwater jet skis. They paralyze him with their rays and he awakens, feeling very hungry, in a tank with other men who are caught by these fish-men who dangle steaks in front of them on fishing lines.

Infantino is well-suited to drawing this underwater civilization and the strange men that inhabit it. It's not a particularly striking piece of work, but the designs work well.

Barry manages to learn that this civilization is called Breda, and the strange fish men who live there are the Bredans, who capture skin divers for their slaves, called the Kota. The Kota are building the homes of the Bredans, but most of them seem to have their memories wiped so they don't fight back. Only Barry seems to be exempt thanks to his speed. The Bredans communicate telepathically through tiny devices they wear around their necks.

I mean, to be fair, Barry is kind of the worst and Ralph knows it.
Barry spots Ralph as part of the crew building the home of a Bredan. After being fed, Barry completes the house at super speed so he can talk to Ralph, but Ralph's also been affected by the mind wipe.
Or maybe Ralph's really hoping Barry will just leave him alone.

Barry manages to jumpstart Ralph's memories by tickling him and making him use his stretching abilities, because I guess his gingold hadn't worn off. And that's how you know this is definitely a Silver Age comic book, kiddos.

The next page sees Ralph and Barry handle a pair of Bredan guards, which off-panel inspires the other Kota to rise up against the Bredans. If it wasn't for the dialogue, you just see a bunch of people standing off to the side, which you might actually miss due to being obscured by shadow.

So, viva la revolution!

 
This is the moment the splash panel was inspired by, with Ralph riding Barry's shoulders and stretching up to wreck the Bredan's assault cars. Infantino does a lot with just three panels, this would be a number of pages in a modern comic.

This gives Barry and Ralph the leverage they need to parley a truce with the Bredans to release the Kota to the surface. Good thing it was done with no threat of violence, right?
Okay, I lied.

After the Kota are released to an island, Barry manages to get a cruise line to take them to the mainland. No mention of if their memories were restored...

Barry takes Ralph back to Sue personally and we get one more look at the happy couple as Barry decides to spend the rest of his weekend off with them.

So, wow, the first story to feature Sue also features Ralph and Barry teaming up to stop a race of underwater people from taking humans as slaves. And the Bredans have seemingly never popped up again, so I guess they learned their lesson.

Sometimes the 14 page limit is a bit too compressed for all of the story to really play out. But if you carefully read all the details, wow, what a story!

The Elongated Man in animation

Although next week's episode of The Flash will feature the live action debut of Ralph Dibny, the character has appeared in official animated projects from Warner Brothers.

 Below are video clips (live at the time of writing) of Ralph's animated appearances, which I limited to speaking roles.

First up is a lengthy clip from "The Greatest Story Never Told," an episode of Justice League Unlimited. Ralph (voiced by Jeremy Piven) is paired up with Booster Gold for "crowd control," but is later called in to help. The episode ends with a reveal that he was instrumental in ending the threat, but the main focus is on what Booster Gold was doing.

Second is another clip from the show, the episode "The Ties That Bind." In a brief, humorous scene, Ralph and Wally West (as the Flash) discuss how they aren't taken seriously. Ralph also appeared in the episode "Clash" and had other non-speaking cameos in the show.

Third is a clip from Batman: The Brave and the Bold's "Journey To The Center of the Bat!" Ralph (voiced by Sean Donnellan) works with Plastic Man (Tom Kenny) to help Batman (Diedrich Bader) take out Baby Face's gang. Ralph also has non-speaking cameos in the show.

While the fourth clip isn't a proper DC animation production, it is released by parent company Warner Brothers. The animated show Mad eventually parodied the Justice League in a song about how the main three heroes aren't really great at being friends. Ralph (voiced by Ralph Garman) not only appears, but has a few lines about trying to borrow money from Superman.


I have been surprised that Ralph hasn't appeared more in the line of DC direct to video animated films. An alternate universe version of him appears in Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths, but doesn't seem to be a speaking role. This "Extruded Man" is a villain and is taken out by the Flash. "Elongated Kid" is mentioned as being dead in Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox.

The Elongated Man's Secret Weapon!

Now onto Ralph's second appearance in The Flash #115. This wasn't the main feature story, just a twelve page backup.

The first page being the splash page!

This particular page plays with a moment later in the story that wasn't depicted quite like that.

This story is written by John Broome and drawn by Carmine Infantino with inks by Murphy Anderson, edited by Julius Schwartz and lettering by Gaspar Saladino.

This might feel pretty standard praise, but take a look at how Infantino's art conveys the scale of the alien invader, and the pressure Ralph is under as well as Barry's seeming helplessness. It might not be high art, but it does a lot in selling this story to you. You want to go ahead and get into the story.

Or else, you probably picked the wrong comic book.
Here we have Ralph doing a show where he apparently can stretch at super speed by catching a girl being fired from a cannon. Infantino is in top form depicting the action with only three panels. The third is triangular-shaped to show what Ralph is doing as well as showing more of the story on this page.

Panel four, it looks as if Barry says Ralph's name out loud, then thinks about how only he knows the Elongated Man's secret identity.

Barry, you should never be allowed to know any secrets, ever.

Final panel on this page is an excellent case for why Ralph should ditch the mask: it makes his face look ugly. I mean, props to Infantino for everything else on the page, but there's too much detail going on here and the end result is that Ralph looks deranged.
Anyway, Ralph has made a fortune from doing stage and TV appearances and is retiring to travel the world. You made good, Ralph. Real good. Retiring at what, 35? Nice.

However, this will be something that'll come back once Ralph moves over to Detective Comics.

I like the handshake panel. If you wanted a nice image to illustrate Ralph and Barry's partnership, there you go. Also, Infantino is in top form.

On these four panels, we see Ralph's trip to Yucatan and his group of Mexican guides. They're depicted pretty well, surprisingly. Broome resists giving them stereotypical dialogue and dialect. Maybe the fact that they do stop when they sense danger might be insulting, but hey, turns out, they weren't wrong.

Panels 3-4, Ralph obviously trails off after he mentions the fruit of the gingo tree and then starts thinking. We begin to see why his secret identity was short lived. Boy can barely keep his mouth closed.
And here is our first glimpse at a gingo tree. And yes, this is the official design and would return later.

One thing I haven't mentioned so far about Silver Age stories is how fast paced they are. In a modern comic, this one page would be at least the better part of an issue.

Again, take a look at how much Infantino puts into the art. You could get the idea of what's happening without the dialogue. Ralph finds the gingo tree, and as he picks a fruit, he sees a bright red light coming from the jungle. He tries to find the source, but runs into an invisible barrier.

Hmm, you know, if this was a modern comic, maybe he'd get squashed against the barrier for a comical effect.
Realizing that this is beyond his capabilities, Ralph calls in his "secret weapon," the Flash! So, basically, the title of this story is "The Flash!" Okay. Nice.

So, Ralph heads to the nearest town (stretching his legs to cover more ground, which is a trick I'm not sure would actually work), then heads back to check out the barrier.

These last two panels are what I want to touch on. While Infantino tries to make it look like Ralph has shrunk, the fact that we see Ralph shoulder up in the first panel kind of ruins the effect because we don't get the entire sense of scale. This is one case where Silver Age comics moving so fast works against it.

Also, while Broome didn't do offensive stereotypical Mexican dialogue, Infantino draws stereotypical Mexicans.
Ralph discovers that there are aliens who have used a device to shrink all living things to "a mite." Since the test is successful, they plan to do this to the entire earth.

Now, apparently the aliens speak in their own language, but they're broadcasting their thoughts in English telepathically for anyone who's around. Maybe this is some super power they have they just can't shut off because it handily gives Ralph all the information he needs to know about them.

Barry arrives in the jungle, but is hit by the same shrinking force. Infantino again fouls up the shrinking effect because it just looks like Barry has entered a heavily overgrown jungle.

However, the towering look of the aliens and Ralph's suddenly limited abilities are well-depicted.
Barry now realizes he's not in a heavy jungle but tall grass. Thank you dialogue for making that clear.

He and Ralph meet up and Ralph fills him in on the alien's scheme. Barry then gets distracted by a rabbit. Now, sure, this infers that Barry is a caring person, but seriously, he interrupts Ralph to point it out.

I do like the image of Barry caring for a rabbit and comforting it, but take a look at what he says. "If those aliens can do this to everyone, scare people too like this—they're evil  and we must stop them."

Barry, Ralph just told you they shrunk everyone and want to do that to the entire planet and take over. I think we're beginning to see why Ralph left to go be a backup in Detective Comics. He needed to hang with someone a bit more on his level. Namely, Batman.


Time to skip a page where Ralph and Barry trail the aliens as they head to the barrier and break through it. Despite being tiny, Ralph and Barry are able to use their powers to take out these two aliens.

Now, I know what I said about how Ralph's stretching out his back should really mess up his center of balance, but apparently, it's no problem at all, so I'll not mention it again. What I will mention is that Ralph seems to have no problem lifting and carrying Barry. In some of his more recent appearances, Ralph was able to expand his muscles, making him far more effective as a fighter. So, although they aren't shown getting larger here, perhaps he's doing something like that.

Also, seemingly, Ralph strangles that alien into submission.

Skipping another page in which Ralph and Barry find the alien camp and overhear them deciding not to wait for the two that our heroes took out and go ahead and activate their device to shrink everyone on Earth. Barry runs to the device and runs back and forth across the end of the machine's barrel, wearing a path into it and making it break.

But for some reason, Barry doesn't run away in time to avoid being spotted and captured. Barry, this is the third time in this story that your actions have been questionable at best.

Also, I'm just going to assume "Gim a dogora" is some alien expletive.

Okay, to get a "stretch boost," Ralph chows down on a gingo fruit. The text says he's just plucked it, but wouldn't it make more sense for it to be the one he plucked earlier? It seems to be perfectly scaled to his hand, as if it had shrunk with him. But if that was true, where did he put it? Maybe that waistband acts as a pocket.

So, this boost lets him save Barry, and the two work together to fire a paralysis ray at the aliens.

And luckily, somehow the ray breaks the shrinking effects because this is the final page and the plot demands a resolution on that point.

The story concludes with Barry deciding to turn the aliens over to the authorities and then running home to Central City to tell Iris about what happened.

Sure, Barry, you just happen to know all about this from a conversation you had with the Flash... It's getting way less convincing, man...

So, Ralph gets to see a gingo fruit, and goes from taking out robbers to taking out space aliens. Also, he's officially retired and traveling the world. Way to go, buddy. Also, Barry Allen is kind of the worst. A few disconnects between the art and text and a couple ugly bits of art. Otherwise, this is one of those wacky backup Silver Age stories that you can't help but love.

Next time, we finally meet the most important person in Ralph's life... The Missus.

Who is Hartley Sawyer?

(This entry features links to several YouTube videos and other video websites. While they were all active at the time of writing, I cannot promise that they'll be valid in the future.)

As tonight's episode of The Flash—"Luck Be A Lady"—finished, we saw the preview for next week's episode, "Elongated Journey Into Night," which features Hartley Sawyer as Ralph Dibny.

This will be the first time the Elongated Man has appeared in an official live action production, and the first time the character has been a featured player outside of the comics. 

Hartley's been in show business for awhile, but is likely not a name you'd recognize. He's had guest spots in TV shows and featured in webseries.
This website has some information on Hartley's early days, but might be suspect. (It and his Wikipedia page give two different dates for his birthday, which is January 25, 1985.) It says he grew up on a farm in New York and featured in some high school plays before attending Boston's Emerson College. He moved to Los Angeles in 2007.

His "big break" was the 2011 TBS comedy Glory Daze, where he played college student Brian Sommers. Glory Daze featured the misadventures of newcomers to a college fraternity in 1986. It ran for only ten episodes.

On television, he had fun guest roles on Don't Trust the B---- In Apartment 23 as Charles the Soy Latte Guy, Brad the model on Jane By Design, a handful of appearances as Peacham Bozeman on GCB, and an episode of NCIS: Los Angeles. He also had a run on classic soap opera The Young and the Restless as Kyle Abbott, taking over from Blake Hood. After eight months, he was let go from the role.


Internet media has been far kinder to Mr. Sawyer, featuring in several webseries. Highly recommended is Geek and Sundry's Caper, in which he plays Dagr, a superhero from a dimension where "Vikings never stopped being a thing." He also featured in his own Courageous Heroes in which he talks to self-made people who made their own way in their respective fields. He also played Jonesy in CW Seed's Saving the Human Race, a cyborg helping one of the last humans find a mate to "mate" with. Finally, he plays Laheer in Go90's Miss 2059, an announcer for an intergalactic battle with more at stake than meets the eye. Also, don't miss him in the short drama film SPiN where he plays a young Wall Street hotshot.

In addition, Hartley is a vegan and owner of two rescue dogs, advocating for rescuing dogs as well as proper care for them. He can be followed on Instagram and Twitter.

Join us next week for a review of "Elongated Journey Into Night" and Hartley's first outing as Ralph Dibny.

The Various Elongated Man costumes

Well, I ran out of time to do another comic breakdown this week, so here's something different.

I Photoshopped Hartley Sawyer—who will be playing Ralph on The Flash TV show—into each of the five unique costumes the Elongated Man has had over the years. Then I did a second picture of color variations on those costumes. With commentary.

#1 - This first simple purple and pale off-blue color first appeared in Ralph's first appearance in The Flash #112. He wore it with a mask (see inset), but by the time of his move to Detective Comics in #327, he had stopped wearing the mask.

#2 - The red, black and gold costume was revealed on the final pages of Detective Comics #350. A little too-inspired by Plastic Man for my liking, but in 3D, it doesn't look bad actually. Some colorists would switch out the red for purple, especially in Detective Comics #359. The red costume would make a major comeback in early 'naughties, and Ralph was seen in it in the tragic Identity Crisis. Some appearances gave Ralph a V-neck that exposed a bit of his chest.

#3 - The half purple and half white costume seems to have first appeared in Justice League of America #252. One of Ralph's better costumes, in my opinion. In Detective Comics #572, he's wearing it with a matching domino mask. I decided not to do that mask.

#4 - This rather unattractive take on the original costume first appeared in Justice League Europe #37. It made Ralph appear too goofy, in my opinion. Also, in the comics, he looked way too tall and slim in it. Like his head had been stretched out.

#5 - The latest costume appeared at the end of Secret Six #12 in 2016. I didn't like it at first, and I still don't like that it's orange and yellow. I've recolored it in shades of purple, and I like that better. The design is good. Colors, not.


1. A more maroon version of the second costume appeared in several issues of Detective Comics. I'm guessing the colorist decided it looked better. Or maybe since Plastic Man did have a series at the time, perhaps they subtly changed it to avoid confusion.

2. This one is mainly personal. When I was a kid, I would photocopy old comics and recolor these black and white copies, mainly so I'd have my own copy. Since Jimmy Olsen's Elastic Lad did a mainly purple costume with green trunks and Plastic Man had red, I suppose I thought Ralph should have his own color, so given the number of color options I had, I picked green.

3. This one is a personal preference twist on the second costume, but some variations of the second costume in Detective Comics looked more regular purple than maroon or red. See point 1.

4. This bizarre twist of the second costume appeared in Detective Comics #357. It also contains an advertisement for the first issue of the then-new Plastic Man series, so perhaps that lends credence to my theory about them moving away from making it primarily red. Or perhaps the colorist on the story heard that Ralph's costume was "red and yellow" and got confused.

5. My initial reaction to the latest costume was negative, but not for the design, but for the bright orange color. Do not put an orange costume on a character whose hair you color orange. It just looked loud and too flashy and while I'm sure you could make the argument that Ralph would do it for attention or to symbolize a new era in his life, I just prefer purple. So here it is, rendered in purple, which I like much better.

The Mystery of the Elongated Man!

The Flash (volume 1) #112 brought us the first Elongated Man appearance, and there he is right on the cover.

Can you imagine seeing this cover back in 1960? There's the Flash running after some fantastic rogue with a pretty incredible power about to catch him.

Um, E.M., you didn't think this through. You have elasticity, but Barry has super speed. By the time you're done thinking that, Barry will totally have caught you. Also, grammar police here, you mean "I can capture him!" The I is missing from the cover, and this scan came from a modern reprint.

So, remember that the original audience was supposed to approach this story with no knowledge as to who the Elongated Man was. He doesn't wear primary colors like most super heroes, he's wearing purple, like a villain. He wears a mask like a robber. This cover is supposed to sell the character as a potential rogue. In fact, when I first saw this cover, I wondered if he was a villain.

Little aside, I recreated this cover in Photoshop as best as I could recently to celebrate Elongated Man coming to The Flash TV show in a couple weeks, played by Hartley Sawyer. The Flash costume isn't the current one, and the Elongated Man costume was based on this original one, sans mask. (Hartley Sawyer is also the face on the blog banner I made.) As I get better pictures to work with, I may be revising the picture to be more in line with the show.

Now onto that splash page.

This is one example of a splash page or panel from the Silver Age. In this case, it's an image not from the story (unlike the cover) that gives you an idea of what the story is about. The text introduces the idea that the Elongated Man is a rival to the Flash instead of being a villain.

Now, we know it's a dream scene and physical elasticity like that is impossible, but Elongated Man (I am ready to start calling him by his proper name, but I'm writing as if you're unfamiliar with the character) would surely be falling over with him shifting his upper body away from the support of his legs.

Also, apparently Barry Allen sleeps in his Flash costume, so if someone happened to walk in on him sleeping, well, secret identity over.

The art style is fairly pleasant. It's done by the legendary Carmine Infantino with inks by Joe Giella. John Broome wrote with Julius Schwartz as editor. Schwartz and Infantino are credited with creating the Elongated Man.

Now onto page 1.

 Who is the neglectful pet owner who let a kitten fall like that? Thank goodness Barry was running by. Infantino nicely uses lines like that to give us the idea of Barry moving at super speed.

But now to panel 3, Barry's blocked from saving the day by the unexpected appearance of the Elongated Man. Again, stretching past the point where his legs should be supporting his upper body. The important thing is, the kitten is okay.

The implications of panels 4 and 5 are perfectly in line with the character of the Elongated Man as he would develop. He stays at the scene of the rescue to talk to the press, here represented by a photographer and Iris West, Barry's girlfriend, who thinks her dialogue.

Now, the final panel, do we assume the Elongated Man is replying to an off-panel question? Because we don't see Iris say anything, she's just thinking.

 In page 2, the story continues as Barry begins to feel upstaged by the Elongated Man as we discover that the newcomer has been getting a lot of press. Flashback to the previous day when the Elongated Man beat the Flash to saving a potential drowning victim.

There's not a lot to say here about the plot, but I will note that if by some chance this was your first exposure to the Flash, this page subtly gives you the basics: that his real name is Barry Allen, that his dual identity is a secret, and how he stores his costume.

I do like that picture of Elongated Man in the final panel. And wow, what a nice mop of hair you have there, sir. Although, once again, that method of stretching out like that shouldn't work. I could imagine someone revisiting this scene and Flash helping Elongated Man anchor himself to the pier, though. That could work. Hmmm, maybe one of the tricks of being elastic means you can shift your center of balance and how you anchor yourself.

 And here, Barry begins to suspect that the Elongated Man is trying to steal the Flash's thunder. Jealous much, Barry? I really hope some of this carries over to the TV show.

Now the narrator steps aside to show us the origin of the Elongated Man, who is actually named Ralph Dibny. So yay, we can call him Ralph now!

There's a lot to read into Ralph's origin here that would eventually get expanded on in the Secret Origins series in the 1980s. Ralph's older brother is named Ken and is later depicted as the typical football star and later mayor. Their hometown would be revealed as Waymore, Nebraska.

So, Ralph was fascinated by a circus contortionist as a kid. Well, Ralph, I got fascinated by one too when I turned 18. His name is Daniel Browning Smith and is considered the most flexible man in the world. And by reading up on him, I know the answer you're looking for, buddy.

Ralph goes to the contortionist's tent to ask him about his secret. Ah, the days when you could depict a kid approaching a strange man without everyone assuming something sinister.

 This first panel is another one of my favorites. We see Ralph taking on a passion he'll follow for years to come. And since we already saw what happened, we realize he comes out on top. So the story has the subtle message of, "It's okay to pursue your dreams." Which is a message some of us needed more of.

Well, Ralph doesn't have such a great time over the next years and hits a low point until he realizes all of the contortionists he's met drink a soda called Gingold.

Gingold is of course the key to Ralph's pursuit. However, in real life, contortionists have a rare condition called hyperflexibility, which is exactly what it sounds like. It allows them to safely dislocate their joints and bend themselves in ways most of us find impossible. While I wouldn't discount that there is likely diet and exercise and certain supplements they can take to keep themselves flexible, that's really what it is, Ralph. You're either born with it or not.

That first panel is clearly intended to make you think of The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Ralph looks rather sinister with his intense look, conveyed by his eyebrows and  his nearly closed mouth. Also, the green tint that you see in color versions vs. how you'd see this in the Showcase Presents reprint collections. Again with the "is this the Flash's latest Rogue?" theme.

Panel 2 perfectly gives us the feeling of Ralph feeling like it was all for nothing. If this panel had no dialogue, we'd still get the idea of what happened.

Okay, now for the next two panels which show Ralph stretching for the first time. And maybe we're supposed to think he's placing the pot back on the window, but the position of the pot looks exactly the same in both panels. So apparently, Ralph can stretch at super speed? And of course, the "ambition" at the end is the teaser as to what Ralph's actual intentions are.

In the next story, we'll find the gingo fruit that is the main ingredient of gingold, but as we're about to not mention it again in this tale, there's later developments with it gingold in the comics. It would be retconned that most people are allergic to gingold, and Ralph is one of the rare people who isn't. Later still, it would be retconned that Ralph's powers are a result of him being a metahuman and drinking the gingold extract or eating the fruit or drinking the soda simply triggered elasticity powers. A future story in The Flash would deal with Ralph exhibiting different powers when he drinks gingold while being carried by Barry at super speed. Personally, I'd like to think Ralph might have several different powers and he's only found a couple of specific triggers for them.

In addition, Ralph says he can stretch "almost indefinitely." At least one later comic would reveal his limit is 100 yards. That's not even a mile, Ralph... I'll just assume that was excitement.

 Barry now begins to suspect Ralph of being a crook who's making a big show for publicity and imagines a scenarios where Ralph might have committed crimes. Again, though, Infantino manages to convey strongly what Barry is thinking with the art. And yes, the pose Barry imagines Ralph in should make him lose his center of balance.

Barry's thoughts are interrupted by a phone call from Iris. Which is a really weird phone call considering Iris says "Hello!" rather than letting Barry do it, and Barry says absolutely nothing but just reacts to recognizing Iris' voice. This is not how typical phone conversations work, guys.

Now, to avoid this blog presenting the entire story, I'm skipping the next two pages. Iris informs Barry that the Flash has close competition for Picture News' Man of the Year. Now determined that Ralph is actually a crook seeking to win over the citizens of Central City, Barry goes to expose Ralph. He heads to a museum that is postponing an exhibit featuring Ming vases to prevent theft. Barry tells them to go ahead and do it and begins patrolling the museum.

 Well, twist, Barry, someone stole them from the warehouse next door. Running to investigate, he finds Ralph exiting the building. Ralph begins to run off, surprised to see Barry running after him.

And here comes the scene we saw rendered on the cover in greater detail. Again, grabbing Barry wasn't going to work, Ralph, he's moving too fast for you.

That last panel shows Ralph looking rather thin. Typically elastic heroes get depicted as skinny guys. Jack Cole's original Plastic Man had broad shoulders, though, and Mr. Fantastic of the Fantastic Four was depicted by Jack Kirby as being pretty ripped. Later artists have certainly drawn them looking much thinner. Ralph would be depicted as looking a bit more toned than super-skinny. Maybe after he discovered the secret of Gingold, he started working out.

 Ralph reveals he apprehended some crooks stealing the vases and fought them. Looks like we missed a good fight. I wonder how Ralph managed to apprehend them. Perhaps he hid in a vase and popped out when the crooks arrived.

Ralph then explains himself to Barry, including giving his real name when the crooks are nearby. They might be knocked out, but they could come to and overhear. At this point, Ralph is doing the secret identity thing, although it would soon vanish and he'd become the first National Publications superhero not to have one. Maybe it's because he's extremely bad at keeping it.

In addition, he says he vows to use his powers only in emergencies or to help people, the story now telling us that he's a hero. Thing is, in later stories, Ralph becomes a gloryhound, seeking media attention. The bit at the beginning where he answers questions from the press fits perfectly with that. This declaration of limiting his use of his powers doesn't.

Barry finds the leader of the gang in a getaway car and manages to stop the car and apprehend the leader. After questioning, the police chief reveals that the crimes pinned on the Elongated Man were committed with a helicopter. I guess the people of Central City sleep very soundly if they can sleep through a helicopter flying so close to the ground.

The story ends with the Flash and Ralph tying for the Man of the Year award, Ralph using his powers to shake Barry's hand from across the room.

It's a nice image to close the story, particularly when you consider the legacy these two characters have together.

Except for the fact that in that last panel, Barry drops Ralph's real first name in a room full of people looking directly at them! Barry, you are the worst.

So, what have we learned? Basically that there's some weird inconsistencies in the story that clash with later established canon. Apparently, contortionists stretch in the DC universe, and Iris and Barry don't know how phone calls are supposed to work. However, that's mainly with the dialogue. Infantino wonderfully draws Ralph in his debut and gives each panel a sense of energy and motion. Perhaps the art isn't the best seen at the time, but I can't complain about it either.

So, that's the debut of Ralph Dibny, the Elongated Man. Join us next time when we go over Ralph's second story.

Behold, the Silver Age!

Probably my all time favorite era of comic books is the Silver Age. And frankly, what's not to love?

Comics have simply been an evolution of storytelling through print. Illustration had finally merged with text to tell stories through a visual medium. Crime and war comic books eventually gave rise to the superhero comic book, in which a costumed character would—with or without superpowers—take it upon themselves to thwart evil forces at work in the world. Captain America, Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, The Flash and Green Lantern were just a handful of characters created in the Golden Age of comics, which is held to have ended in the mid-1950s.

The Golden Age saw many innovations from various comics creators. Virtually any type of character was on the table. Horror comics existed and went in many gruesome and bizarre directions. Subject matter was fairly open, for example, an early Superman story saw him defend a woman against her physically abusive husband by beating him.

People point to many things as starting the Silver Age, but really, I think we have to give a mind to a book titled Seduction of the Innocent, which blamed comic books for youth delinquency and often misinterpreted things in comics as negative. This gave rise to the Comics Code Authority, which was used as a seal on the covers of comics for decades to come to say as to whether or not a comic book met certain guidelines of acceptability. This was not a requirement, of course, but if your comic book didn't have it, good luck getting retailers to sell it, and advertisers might pull their ads.

Comics would be produced by people who cared about them, then read by people, and some of those people might be young kids who decide they wanted to make comics as well and worked to do it. So as comic books continued, they evolved along with the audience. About six years ago, the major comics companies abandoned the Comics Code Authority and it became defunct.

However, back to the Silver Age. Instead of pushing the envelope for the limits of violence and such they could show, in came monsters, aliens and other fantastic events.

In short, they went for stories that could be viewed as fucking crazy.

National Publications (now DC Comics) would be the big one to reintroduce superheroes. New versions of the Flash and the Green Lantern were introduced, and in fact became the standard incarnations of the characters despite being the second heroes with those names. In 1960, they introduced the Justice League of America, in which their biggest heroes would team up. The Flash would eventually introduce the multiverse concept, which allowed for a lot of amazing stories to eventually be written.

Over at Atlas Comics, writer Stanley Leiber (better known as Stan Lee) would be tasked to come up with a team of superheroes, and he and Jack Kirby created The Fantastic Four, debuting in late 1961. Of course, Atlas was soon rebranded to Marvel Comics. This would lead to the creation and reintroduction of many classic Marvel characters, and the introduction of The Avengers. This led to the interconnected Marvel universe, in which many of the superheroes depicted in their line of comics would live in the same version of New York and interact with each other.

So, basically, not only was the Silver Age extremely fun, it basically set the standard for the modern range of superheroes. What's not to love?

So, as you may have noticed, this blog is dedicated to the Elongated Man. He was introduced in 1961, in The Flash (volume 1) #112. He was a character with the power of elasticity, able to stretch his body to superhuman lengths.

The Elongated Man wasn't the first character to have this power. Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #58 had the titular character exposed to a liquid kryptonite that allowed him to stretch. But previously, Jack Cole had introduced Plastic Man in Quality Comics' Police Comics in 1941. Plastic Man could stretch and generally reshape his body into any imaginable form, including compressing into small shapes. Quality didn't survive the decline of sales thanks to Seduction of the Innocent and sold many of their characters to National, making Plastic Man one of National's characters.

But was Elongated Man a copycat Plastic Man? According to Brian Cronin of Comic Book Resources, maybe, but unlike the common belief, it's not likely that they would have just used Plastic Man if they'd thought of him.

There is a famous story that Julius Schwartz said that he only came up with the idea for Elongated Man because he didn’t know that DC had the rights to Plastic Man. If he had known, he would have just used Plastic Man (DC had purchased most of Quality Comics characters, including Plastic Man, when Quality went out of business in 1956).

However, I think that Schwartz’s story has been misconstrued a bit over the years.

Schwartz’s recollection of it came years later, when he noted that he didn’t know (or that he had forgotten) that DC had the rights to Plastic Man when he came up with Elongated Man. He did note that perhaps he would have named Elongated Man Plastic Man, but that is just an after-the-fact commentary.

So it really comes down to us determining whether we think that actually would have happened. So this is truly just a case of me having to make a judgment call.

As it was, Elongated Man was a one-off character who was never meant to recur. He turned out to be surprisingly popular with the fans, so they brought him back (and he then proved so popular that they eventually gave him his own feature in Detective Comics). It seems highly unlikely to me that Schwartz would have chosen this particular story to revive Plastic Man.

Carmine Infantino recalled to Jim Amash that Schwartz never actually mentioned Plastic Man at all at the time.

So I believe that even had Schwartz known that DC owned the rights, I don’t think it would have affected the story much. After all, Mort Weisigner had already introduced ANOTHER elastic hero recently at the time (Jimmy Olsen’s Elastic Lad), so it wasn’t like it was out of the ordinary to have an elastic hero other than Plastic Man.

Add in the factor that the Elongated Man's debut story features a plot point of him being suspected to be a criminal and the reappearance of a hero character would spoil the reveal.

Anyway, that's the setting that the Elongated Man was introduced in.

Next time, we're going to look at his first story.

Where Ralph could fit in James Gunn's DCU (and Plastic Man too!)

 So, hi! I haven't forgotten about this blog, it's just time gets away from me, there's other stuff I want to handle. If I could...